Painful Quandary
Played in 22,584 Black decks
Color Identity Spread
31.3% Black
All commanders (30)
- Tinybones, Bauble Burglar relevance 3.36 · 67.5% (4,255 of 6,300 decks)
- Tinybones, Trinket Thief relevance 3.11 · 69.8% (2,028 of 2,904 decks)
- Tergrid, God of Fright // Tergrid's Lantern relevance 2.89 · 49.7% (3,634 of 7,319 decks)
- Aclazotz, Deepest Betrayal // Temple of the Dead relevance 2.53 · 64.4% (617 of 958 decks)
- The Raven Man relevance 2.13 · 54.4% (335 of 616 decks)
- Mai, Scornful Striker relevance 2.08 · 52.6% (311 of 591 decks)
- Tinybones, Pocket Nuisance relevance 2.01 · 50.3% (288 of 572 decks)
- Tourach, Dread Cantor relevance 1.90 · 55.8% (169 of 303 decks)
- Tinybones, the Pickpocket relevance 1.71 · 32.2% (393 of 1,220 decks)
- Kuroki, Thief of Talents relevance 1.67 · 37.1% (233 of 628 decks)
- The Haunt of Hightower relevance 1.64 · 53.9% (89 of 165 decks)
- Cao Cao, Lord of Wei relevance 1.63 · 65.2% (60 of 92 decks)
- Erebos, God of the Dead relevance 1.57 · 30.9% (270 of 875 decks)
- Seizan, Perverter of Truth relevance 1.55 · 33.4% (208 of 623 decks)
- Sheoldred // The True Scriptures relevance 1.50 · 29.8% (235 of 788 decks)
- Rankle, Master of Pranks relevance 1.48 · 32.4% (176 of 543 decks)
- Infernal Kirin relevance 1.42 · 49.6% (56 of 113 decks)
- Maralen of the Mornsong relevance 1.34 · 22.7% (285 of 1,253 decks)
- Sheoldred, the Apocalypse relevance 1.32 · 15.5% (1,147 of 7,409 decks)
- Ob Nixilis, Unshackled relevance 1.30 · 25.9% (164 of 634 decks)
- Valgavoth, Terror Eater relevance 1.27 · 19.9% (328 of 1,652 decks)
- Urgoros, the Empty One relevance 1.20 · 49.2% (30 of 61 decks)
- The Master of Lake-town relevance 1.12 · 20.5% (151 of 735 decks)
- Greel, Mind Raker relevance 1.12 · 42.6% (29 of 68 decks)
- He Who Hungers relevance 1.03 · 35.7% (30 of 84 decks)
- Anowon, the Ruin Sage relevance 1.02 · 26.3% (52 of 198 decks)
- Olinda the Oblivious relevance 1.00 · 16.1% (184 of 1,146 decks)
- Braids, Arisen Nightmare relevance 1.00 · 12.0% (534 of 4,446 decks)
- Azula, Ruthless Firebender relevance 1.00 · 24.1% (58 of 241 decks)
- Kyoki, Sanity's Eclipse relevance 0.94 · 37.7% (20 of 53 decks)
All most relevant (30)
- Waste Not relevance 1.35 · 56.2% (12,690 of 22,584 decks)
- Oppression relevance 1.25 · 46.2% (10,424 of 22,584 decks)
- Geth's Grimoire relevance 1.20 · 42.6% (9,623 of 22,584 decks)
- Megrim relevance 1.10 · 35.4% (8,005 of 22,584 decks)
- Syphon Mind relevance 1.09 · 47.8% (10,788 of 22,584 decks)
- Liliana's Caress relevance 1.08 · 36.0% (8,132 of 22,584 decks)
- Dark Deal relevance 1.07 · 45.7% (10,311 of 22,584 decks)
- The Raven Man relevance 1.05 · 34.6% (7,804 of 22,584 decks)
- Rankle, Master of Pranks relevance 1.03 · 44.4% (10,036 of 22,584 decks)
- Bandit's Talent relevance 1.02 · 33.1% (7,479 of 22,584 decks)
- Vicious Rumors relevance 1.00 · 32.9% (7,424 of 22,584 decks)
- Bottomless Pit relevance 1.00 · 32.1% (7,256 of 22,584 decks)
- Burglar Rat relevance 0.99 · 41.3% (9,325 of 22,584 decks)
- Elderfang Disciple relevance 0.97 · 33.3% (7,516 of 22,584 decks)
- Virus Beetle relevance 0.96 · 33.7% (7,608 of 22,584 decks)
- Tourach, Dread Cantor relevance 0.95 · 29.1% (6,561 of 22,584 decks)
- Necrogen Mists relevance 0.91 · 27.9% (6,296 of 22,584 decks)
- Aclazotz, Deepest Betrayal // Temple of the Dead relevance 0.91 · 31.2% (7,039 of 22,584 decks)
- Sangromancer relevance 0.88 · 35.4% (7,997 of 22,584 decks)
- Fell Specter relevance 0.88 · 25.6% (5,788 of 22,584 decks)
- Liliana of the Veil relevance 0.85 · 30.4% (6,860 of 22,584 decks)
- Necrogoyf relevance 0.85 · 25.6% (5,776 of 22,584 decks)
- Delirium Skeins relevance 0.82 · 23.9% (5,399 of 22,584 decks)
- Mindslicer relevance 0.81 · 25.2% (5,684 of 22,584 decks)
- Nezumi Informant relevance 0.81 · 27.1% (6,121 of 22,584 decks)
- Smallpox relevance 0.77 · 25.7% (5,804 of 22,584 decks)
- Tinybones, Trinket Thief relevance 0.77 · 22.8% (5,160 of 22,584 decks)
- Tinybones Joins Up relevance 0.76 · 24.0% (5,430 of 22,584 decks)
- Raiders' Wake relevance 0.76 · 20.9% (4,724 of 22,584 decks)
- Entropic Battlecruiser relevance 0.75 · 21.0% (4,742 of 22,584 decks)
All creatures (20)
- The Raven Man relevance 1.05 · 34.6% (7,804 of 22,584 decks)
- Rankle, Master of Pranks relevance 1.03 · 44.4% (10,036 of 22,584 decks)
- Burglar Rat relevance 0.99 · 41.3% (9,325 of 22,584 decks)
- Elderfang Disciple relevance 0.97 · 33.3% (7,516 of 22,584 decks)
- Virus Beetle relevance 0.96 · 33.7% (7,608 of 22,584 decks)
- Tourach, Dread Cantor relevance 0.95 · 29.1% (6,561 of 22,584 decks)
- Aclazotz, Deepest Betrayal // Temple of the Dead relevance 0.91 · 31.2% (7,039 of 22,584 decks)
- Sangromancer relevance 0.88 · 35.4% (7,997 of 22,584 decks)
- Fell Specter relevance 0.88 · 25.6% (5,788 of 22,584 decks)
- Necrogoyf relevance 0.85 · 25.6% (5,776 of 22,584 decks)
- Mindslicer relevance 0.81 · 25.2% (5,684 of 22,584 decks)
- Nezumi Informant relevance 0.81 · 27.1% (6,121 of 22,584 decks)
- Tinybones, Trinket Thief relevance 0.77 · 22.8% (5,160 of 22,584 decks)
- Cunning Lethemancer relevance 0.74 · 20.0% (4,527 of 22,584 decks)
- Tinybones, Bauble Burglar relevance 0.67 · 20.0% (4,506 of 22,584 decks)
- Hecteyes relevance 0.66 · 19.4% (4,379 of 22,584 decks)
- Tergrid, God of Fright // Tergrid's Lantern relevance 0.64 · 23.7% (5,351 of 22,584 decks)
- Hypnotic Specter relevance 0.58 · 14.8% (3,341 of 22,584 decks)
- Plaguecrafter relevance 0.55 · 33.1% (7,476 of 22,584 decks)
- The Haunt of Hightower relevance 0.51 · 13.0% (2,932 of 22,584 decks)
All artifacts (2)
- Geth's Grimoire relevance 1.20 · 42.6% (9,623 of 22,584 decks)
- Entropic Battlecruiser relevance 0.75 · 21.0% (4,742 of 22,584 decks)
All enchantments (13)
- Waste Not relevance 1.35 · 56.2% (12,690 of 22,584 decks)
- Oppression relevance 1.25 · 46.2% (10,424 of 22,584 decks)
- Megrim relevance 1.10 · 35.4% (8,005 of 22,584 decks)
- Liliana's Caress relevance 1.08 · 36.0% (8,132 of 22,584 decks)
- Bandit's Talent relevance 1.02 · 33.1% (7,479 of 22,584 decks)
- Bottomless Pit relevance 1.00 · 32.1% (7,256 of 22,584 decks)
- Necrogen Mists relevance 0.91 · 27.9% (6,296 of 22,584 decks)
- Tinybones Joins Up relevance 0.76 · 24.0% (5,430 of 22,584 decks)
- Raiders' Wake relevance 0.76 · 20.9% (4,724 of 22,584 decks)
- Court of Ambition relevance 0.66 · 18.5% (4,169 of 22,584 decks)
- Hopeless Nightmare relevance 0.60 · 17.2% (3,891 of 22,584 decks)
- Bloodchief Ascension relevance 0.55 · 22.5% (5,092 of 22,584 decks)
- Quest for the Nihil Stone relevance 0.54 · 13.0% (2,944 of 22,584 decks)
All sorceries (12)
- Syphon Mind relevance 1.09 · 47.8% (10,788 of 22,584 decks)
- Dark Deal relevance 1.07 · 45.7% (10,311 of 22,584 decks)
- Vicious Rumors relevance 1.00 · 32.9% (7,424 of 22,584 decks)
- Delirium Skeins relevance 0.82 · 23.9% (5,399 of 22,584 decks)
- Smallpox relevance 0.77 · 25.7% (5,804 of 22,584 decks)
- Duress relevance 0.72 · 25.3% (5,725 of 22,584 decks)
- Rankle's Prank relevance 0.69 · 19.4% (4,371 of 22,584 decks)
- Mind Rake relevance 0.68 · 18.4% (4,147 of 22,584 decks)
- Torment of Hailfire relevance 0.59 · 28.5% (6,445 of 22,584 decks)
- Pilfer relevance 0.57 · 14.8% (3,351 of 22,584 decks)
- Arterial Flow relevance 0.53 · 13.7% (3,086 of 22,584 decks)
- Thoughtseize relevance 0.52 · 17.0% (3,842 of 22,584 decks)
All planeswalkers (2)
- Liliana of the Veil relevance 0.85 · 30.4% (6,860 of 22,584 decks)
- Liliana, Waker of the Dead relevance 0.60 · 17.5% (3,946 of 22,584 decks)
All utility lands (1)
- Geier Reach Sanitarium relevance 0.91 · 39.6% (8,933 of 22,584 decks)
EDH data for Painful Quandary: adoption stats, associated cards, and its most popular commanders, from 22,584 real decks.