Painful Memories
Played in 69 Black decks
630+27+8+4+4+7+
Color Identity Spread
23.8% Black
Commanders
Lobelia, Defender of Bag End 9.0% of decks
Lobelia, Defender of Bag End 9.0% of decks
Gonti, Night Minister 1.1% of decks
Gonti, Night Minister 1.1% of decks
Nashi, Moon Sage's Scion 1.3% of decks
Nashi, Moon Sage's Scion 1.3% of decks
Shauku, Endbringer 1.4% of decks
Shauku, Endbringer 1.4% of decks
Spirit of the Night 1.2% of decks
Spirit of the Night 1.2% of decks
Tymaret, Chosen from Death 1.1% of decks
Tymaret, Chosen from Death 1.1% of decks
Most Relevant
Misinformation 58.0% of decks
Misinformation 58.0% of decks
Lantern of Insight 36.2% of decks
Lantern of Insight 36.2% of decks
Thieving Varmint 47.8% of decks
Thieving Varmint 47.8% of decks
Cunning Rhetoric 40.6% of decks
Cunning Rhetoric 40.6% of decks
Court of Locthwain 34.8% of decks
Court of Locthwain 34.8% of decks
Dauthi Horror 33.3% of decks
Dauthi Horror 33.3% of decks
That's every commander.
All commanders (6)
- Lobelia, Defender of Bag End relevance 2.52 · 9.0% (9 of 100 decks)
- Gonti, Night Minister relevance 2.34 · 1.1% (28 of 2,641 decks)
- Nashi, Moon Sage's Scion relevance 0.81 · 1.3% (2 of 150 decks)
- Shauku, Endbringer relevance 0.51 · 1.4% (1 of 73 decks)
- Spirit of the Night relevance 0.50 · 1.2% (1 of 84 decks)
- Tymaret, Chosen from Death relevance 0.48 · 1.1% (1 of 95 decks)
All most relevant (30)
- Misinformation relevance 3.36 · 58.0% (40 of 69 decks)
- Lantern of Insight relevance 2.06 · 36.2% (25 of 69 decks)
- Thieving Varmint relevance 1.76 · 47.8% (33 of 69 decks)
- Cunning Rhetoric relevance 1.61 · 40.6% (28 of 69 decks)
- Court of Locthwain relevance 1.51 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Horror relevance 1.51 · 33.3% (23 of 69 decks)
- Scheming Symmetry relevance 1.43 · 44.9% (31 of 69 decks)
- Outrageous Robbery relevance 1.37 · 31.9% (22 of 69 decks)
- Changeling Outcast relevance 1.37 · 42.0% (29 of 69 decks)
- Brainstealer Dragon relevance 1.34 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Staff of Eden, Vault's Key relevance 1.32 · 27.5% (19 of 69 decks)
- Tormented Soul relevance 1.32 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Gix, Yawgmoth Praetor relevance 1.29 · 42.0% (29 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Slayer relevance 1.26 · 29.0% (20 of 69 decks)
- Predators' Hour relevance 1.22 · 26.1% (18 of 69 decks)
- Cruelclaw's Heist relevance 1.19 · 29.0% (20 of 69 decks)
- Grim Hireling relevance 1.19 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Vampire Cutthroat relevance 1.10 · 27.5% (19 of 69 decks)
- Gonti, Lord of Luxury relevance 1.05 · 29.0% (20 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Warlord relevance 1.05 · 20.3% (14 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Cutthroat relevance 0.97 · 17.4% (12 of 69 decks)
- Rev, Tithe Extractor relevance 0.96 · 23.2% (16 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Ghoul relevance 0.96 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Blade of Selves relevance 0.95 · 23.2% (16 of 69 decks)
- Faerie Dreamthief relevance 0.91 · 21.7% (15 of 69 decks)
- Mastermind Plum relevance 0.90 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Heartless Conscription relevance 0.87 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Nether Traitor relevance 0.86 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Tempting Contract relevance 0.80 · 14.5% (10 of 69 decks)
- Vault Skirge relevance 0.80 · 17.4% (12 of 69 decks)
All creatures (27)
- Thieving Varmint relevance 1.76 · 47.8% (33 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Horror relevance 1.51 · 33.3% (23 of 69 decks)
- Changeling Outcast relevance 1.37 · 42.0% (29 of 69 decks)
- Brainstealer Dragon relevance 1.34 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Tormented Soul relevance 1.32 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Gix, Yawgmoth Praetor relevance 1.29 · 42.0% (29 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Slayer relevance 1.26 · 29.0% (20 of 69 decks)
- Grim Hireling relevance 1.19 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Vampire Cutthroat relevance 1.10 · 27.5% (19 of 69 decks)
- Gonti, Lord of Luxury relevance 1.05 · 29.0% (20 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Warlord relevance 1.05 · 20.3% (14 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Cutthroat relevance 0.97 · 17.4% (12 of 69 decks)
- Rev, Tithe Extractor relevance 0.96 · 23.2% (16 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Ghoul relevance 0.96 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Faerie Dreamthief relevance 0.91 · 21.7% (15 of 69 decks)
- Mastermind Plum relevance 0.90 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Nether Traitor relevance 0.86 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Vault Skirge relevance 0.80 · 17.4% (12 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Voidwalker relevance 0.80 · 42.0% (29 of 69 decks)
- Vashta Nerada relevance 0.79 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Black Cat, Cunning Thief relevance 0.79 · 17.4% (12 of 69 decks)
- Gingerbrute relevance 0.78 · 17.4% (12 of 69 decks)
- Pilfering Imp relevance 0.76 · 14.5% (10 of 69 decks)
- Crabomination relevance 0.69 · 14.5% (10 of 69 decks)
- Nashi, Moon Sage's Scion relevance 0.69 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Eyetwitch relevance 0.66 · 11.6% (8 of 69 decks)
- Orochi Soul-Reaver relevance 0.66 · 14.5% (10 of 69 decks)
All artifacts (8)
- Lantern of Insight relevance 2.06 · 36.2% (25 of 69 decks)
- Staff of Eden, Vault's Key relevance 1.32 · 27.5% (19 of 69 decks)
- Blade of Selves relevance 0.95 · 23.2% (16 of 69 decks)
- Tempting Contract relevance 0.80 · 14.5% (10 of 69 decks)
- Helm of Awakening relevance 0.80 · 17.4% (12 of 69 decks)
- Wishclaw Talisman relevance 0.79 · 30.4% (21 of 69 decks)
- Panharmonicon relevance 0.78 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Nimblewright Schematic relevance 0.64 · 11.6% (8 of 69 decks)
All enchantments (4)
- Cunning Rhetoric relevance 1.61 · 40.6% (28 of 69 decks)
- Court of Locthwain relevance 1.51 · 34.8% (24 of 69 decks)
- Dauthi Embrace relevance 0.67 · 15.9% (11 of 69 decks)
- Parker Luck relevance 0.65 · 13.0% (9 of 69 decks)
All instants (4)
- Misinformation relevance 3.36 · 58.0% (40 of 69 decks)
- Outrageous Robbery relevance 1.37 · 31.9% (22 of 69 decks)
- Fake Your Own Death relevance 0.71 · 27.5% (19 of 69 decks)
- Undying Malice relevance 0.69 · 30.4% (21 of 69 decks)
All sorceries (7)
- Scheming Symmetry relevance 1.43 · 44.9% (31 of 69 decks)
- Predators' Hour relevance 1.22 · 26.1% (18 of 69 decks)
- Cruelclaw's Heist relevance 1.19 · 29.0% (20 of 69 decks)
- Heartless Conscription relevance 0.87 · 18.8% (13 of 69 decks)
- Head Games relevance 0.68 · 11.6% (8 of 69 decks)
- Praetor's Grasp relevance 0.66 · 20.3% (14 of 69 decks)
- Blood Money relevance 0.64 · 17.4% (12 of 69 decks)
EDH data for Painful Memories: adoption stats, associated cards, and its most popular commanders, from 69 real decks.





































